Monday, April 18, 2016

Smashing Verdict in DePuy Pinnacle Hip Trial

April 19, 2016 - A Texas jury recently returned a substantial settlement in favor of five plaintiffs who claimed their DePuy metal Pinnacle hip devices failed. The plaintiffs in this bellwether case alleged the DePuy Pinnacle metal hip device caused significant health problems, such as metallosis and metal toxicity.

 

Specific symptoms included severe inflammation, deterioration and death of bone and tissue, chronic pain in the hip, groin and thigh areas, loosening of the device and the necessity for Pinnacle revision surgery. When the metal ions which have sheared away from the device during periods of activity enter the bloodstream, a number of additional serious health symptoms can occur.

 

DePuy’s Earlier Requests Denied

Prior to the recent settlement, DePuy called for numerous requests to divide the trial into two parts. DePuy sought to gain a judgment on a specific set of legal issues without looking at all aspects, and also submitted more than ten requests for a mistrial. All of those requests were denied. The bellwether trial lasted two months, followed by days of jury deliberation.

 

The judge presiding over this bellwether trial ruled on January 8, 2016, that the five cases should be consolidated for trial due to the significant number of common issues between the plaintiffs. Those commonalities included similar injuries to the five patients, similar Pinnacle surgical procedures, and similar warning to the plaintiffs’ doctors.

 

Pinnacle Approved by FDA in 2000—Metal Liner Discontinued in 2013

The DePuy Pinnacle metal hip gained FDA approval in 2000, and, like the recalled DePuy ASR, offered several options for patients, including a metal-on-metal ball and socket as well as ceramic-on-polyethylene, ceramic-on-metal and metal-on-polyethylene versions. The goal was to give surgeons the freedom to choose the best surface for specific patients, based on the activity level of the patient, as well as the patient’s age and body type. The metal-on-metal system generated a significant number of adverse reactions among Pinnacle patients, yet while the ASR was recalled, DePuy refused to recall the Pinnacle, however discontinued the metal liner in 2013.

 

Despite Adverse Reports and Lawsuits DePuy Continues to Claim Pinnacle is Safe

Despite the more than 1,300 adverse event reports submitted to the FDA regarding the Pinnacle and the fact that by July 2015 there were more than 7,000 Pinnacle plaintiffs with suits filed in the Northern District of Texas, DePuy continues to maintain the Pinnacle device is safe. The first bellwether trial was a win for Johnson & Johnson, dealing an early blow to plaintiffs. A Texas jury unanimously found in favor of Johnson & Johnson on all counts, rejecting the plaintiff’s claims of negligence, failure to warn and defective design, following an eight-week trial.

 

Johnson & Johnson built on that first win, releasing a statement which defended the Pinnacle’s track record for effectiveness and safety. While that first major loss for Pinnacle patients was felt to be a big obstacle for the next bellwether trial, today’s major win should offer injured Pinnacle patients renewed hope. It is not too late for those who have suffered injury from a Pinnacle hip device to speak to a DePuy Pinnacle hip attorney and join the thousands of others who are seeking damages from Johnson & Johnson.

Print
0 Comments
Please login or register to post comments.

WARNING: Do not send any information in any email through this website if you consider the information confidential or privileged.

I understand that by submitting my contact information to Sullo & Sullo LLP for review, I consent to messages regarding this legal matter as well as marketing for other potential legal matters in the future without limitation at standard messaging and data rates unless terminated by me in writing. I further understand that my submission of any and all information in response to this website does NOT create a lawyer-client relationship between myself and Sullo & Sullo, LLP and/or its lawyers, and that any and all information submitted is NOT confidential or privileged. I further acknowledge that, unless Sullo & Sullo, LLP subsequently enters into an Attorney-Client relationship with me, any and all information I provide will NOT be treated as confidential or privileged, and any such information may be used against me and/or for the benefit of current or future clients of Sullo & Sullo, LLP. ...READ ENTIRE DISCLAIMER
Receive an Immediate Response
ANDREW SULLO IS A TOP 100 NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYER 2013 • 2014 • 2015 • 2016 • 2017 • 2018 • 2019
Obtener una Respuesta Inmediata
Andrew Sullo – 100 Mejores Abogados Nacional | 2013 • 2014 • 2015 • 2016 • 2017


4.6/5.0

STARS ON YELP
WITH OVER 400 REVIEWS*

*AS OF JANUARY 2024



Andrew Sullo has been named a

TOP 100 NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYER*
2013-2024

*BY THE NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYERS

 

CALL NOW FOR A FREE LEGAL CONSULTATION
(800) 730-7607
CALL NOW FOR A FREE LEGAL CONSULTATION (713) 839-9026 CALL NOW FOR A FREE LEGAL CONSULTATION (713) 335-9485


Andrew Sullo is a recipient of the

AVVO CLIENT'S CHOICE AWARD*
2016, 2017, 2019-2024

*GIVEN BY AVVO


Justice

Andrew Sullo is a Member of the

AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF JUSTICE
2013-2024

*GRANTED BY THE AAJ

 

IF YOU OR A LOVED ONE WERE SERIOUSLY INJURED DUE TO THE NEGLIGENCE OF ANOTHER, CONTACT SULLO & SULLO IMMEDIATELY.
CALL NOW
(800) 730-7607
CALL NOW
(713) 839-9026
CALL NOW
(713) 335-9485

GET LEGAL HELP