MENU

Who Are the Talcum Powder Ovarian Cancer Experts and What Do They Say?

Talcum Powder Lawsuits: A Look at the recent Daubert Ruling in the MDL

March 20, 2022 – The long-awaited Daubert decision was given by Chief Judge Wolfson, the judge overseeing the Johnson & Johnson baby powder ovarian cancer multidistrict litigation at the end of April 2020. Wolfson gave a 141-page opinion that comprehensively analyzed the factors which will determine whether scientific expert witnesses (both for the plaintiffs and for the defendants) will be allowed to testify on various issues that are critical to the cases pending on baby powder ovarian cancer.

One of the most prominent issues at hand was the defendant’s (Johnson & Johnson) claim that the studies done by Dr. Longo that found asbestos in talcum powder were “junk science.” This, despite the fact that in October 2019, the FDA reported J & J’s own laboratory identified trace amounts of asbestos in their baby powder products that contained talcum powder. While the Daubert decision was pending, emerging reports were brought to the Court’s attention, although whether plaintiffs’ experts will utilize data from these reports or rely on previous findings is unknown.

Talcum Powder Ovarian Cancer Experts – An inflammation and oxidative stress expert for the plaintiffs, Dr. Ghassad Saed found a causal connection between the relationship between inflammation and other pathological conditions in ovarian cells and the pathogenesis of ovarian cancer. In layman’s terms, Dr. Saed found that the introduction of particles of talcum powder into normal ovarian cells clearly leads to oxidative stress and inflammation—both known to cause ovarian cancer. While J & J lawyers took issue with the methods, procedures, and conclusions from Dr. Saed, his study was found reliable under Daubert standards. That being said, Dr. Saed will only be allowed to testify that talcum powder can cause oxidative stress and inflammation and will not be able to offer his opinions regarding the connection between ovarian cancer and talcum powder.

Dr. Longo, another of the plaintiffs’ baby powder ovarian cancer experts, tested 72 samples of talcum powder taken from railroad cars and containers over a period of four decades for asbestos contamination. Dr. Longo used a polarized light microscope and a transmission electron microscope in his study, concluding that 50 containers out of the 72 tested rendered a 69 percent positive result—both for the Johnson & Johnson baby powder with talc containers and the Shower to Shower containers, as well as for the railroad cars—for asbestos. Dr. Long’s conclusion was that it was more likely than not that those using J & J’s Shower to Shower and Baby Powder with Talc would likely have been exposed to “significant airborne levels of both regulated amphibole asbestos and fibrous (asbestiform) talc.”  Dr. Longo will be allowed to discuss the asbestos findings but will not be allowed to say that women using the powders were exposed to asbestos.

Drs. McTiernan, Carson, and Clarke-Pearson have been called by the plaintiffs’ attorneys to testify regarding causation—whether those using talcum powder products were exposed to a higher risk of being diagnosed with ovarian cancer. These three doctors would testify that when women use talcum powder in the genital region for the purpose of feminine hygiene, their risk of being diagnosed with ovarian cancer significantly increases—and the court was satisfied that these three doctors were qualified to argue causation based on properly conducted control studies. In fact, the court found there was sufficient scientific evidence to support the inclusion of experts from both sides—even though the body of relevant scientific evidence could be “open to different interpretations.”

How an Experienced Baby Powder Ovarian Cancer Lawyer Can Help – If you or a loved one have been diagnosed with ovarian cancer after using Johnson & Johnson Baby Powder with talc or Shower to Shower with talc for feminine hygiene, it could be very beneficial for you to speak with an experienced talcum powder ovarian cancer lawyer who can answer your questions and help you determine whether a talcum powder ovarian cancer lawsuit is right for you.

Related Posts

Free Case Review

"*" indicates required fields

Name*
Are you a Sullo client?*
Preferred Language*
WARNING: Do not send any information in any email through this website if you consider the information confidential or privileged.

Awards

CALL NOW FOR A FREE LEGAL CONSULTATION

(800) 730-7607

Categories

Categories

Google Reviews

Mike McLin
2 days ago
Sullo & Sullo was responsive and courteous with my questions up to my court date. I got my traffic ticket dismissed with the help of Sullo & Sullo.
Response from the owner:Mike, it's great to hear your ticket got dismissed and that the legal team kept you in the loop the whole way through. That kind of back-and-forth matters, especially when you're waiting on a court date, and we're glad the experience felt that way from your end. Thanks for taking a moment to share this with us.
Raymond Duran
2 days ago
They got my ticket dismissed.
Response from the owner:Raymond, getting that ticket dismissed is exactly the kind of news we love to hear. Thanks for letting us know how it went.
nam
2 days ago
I had a citation that ended up causing me to go to court multiple times, and as soon as I hired Sullo & Sullo as my attorneys, it was able to be dismissed by Phillip! From our short conversation, he assured me that I would pay nothing and I thought he was such a good talker! Thank you to him for dismissing my case, I would definitely go back in the future!
Response from the owner:Nam, what a great thing to read today. Going through a citation that sent you back to court more than once sounds genuinely frustrating, and we're so glad Phillip was able to get it dismissed for you. I'll make sure he sees this.
Lawrence Kitzberger
2 days ago
Unfortunately I've had to use the services of Sullo & Sullo twice. Both times they have gone above and beyond helping me. They have done their job to the fullest. I highly recommend Sullo & Sullo for your traffic related ticket.
Response from the owner:Lawrence, two visits is never how anyone hopes things go, but knowing the legal team at Sullo & Sullo Attorneys at Law was there for you both times and came through for you each one really does mean a lot to hear. We're glad your traffic tickets were handled the way they should've been, and we appreciate you saying so publicly.
vanessa toledo
2 days ago
This is my third time using this law firm and I promise you you will not be disappointed always get a ticket dismissed. Thank you again for your services
Response from the owner:Vanessa, three times now, and that kind of loyalty genuinely means a lot to everyone at Sullo & Sullo Attorneys at Law. Hearing that your ticket got dismissed each time is exactly what the legal team works toward, and knowing you'd come back again says everything. Thank you for the trust you've placed in us.
bronco cashb
2 days ago
Response from the owner:Bronco, thanks for the five stars. Everyone at Sullo & Sullo Attorneys at Law appreciates it.
matthew b
2 days ago
Extremely easy. I called Sullo and Sullo. Paid less than the ticket cost and they handled everything. Text message/email reminders. All I had to do was show up! Thank you!!!
Response from the owner:Matthew, that's exactly how it should go. Paying less than the ticket cost and not having to stress about the details is what the legal team at Sullo & Sullo Attorneys at Law is there for. Really glad the reminders kept everything smooth on your end. Thanks for sharing this!