Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Should I Get a Revision for My DePuy Pinnacle Hip Implant?

April 09, 2015 - If you were implanted with a DePuy Pinnacle hip device, and have been keeping up with the litigation concerning the Pinnacle, you may wonder whether you should undergo DePuy Pinnacle hip revision surgery. When a hip implant fails, or has caused serious issues such as DePuy Pinnacle hip metallosis, a doctor may advise the patient to have the implant removed and replaced with a safer model.

 

In this case, the decision to have DePuy Pinnacle hip revision surgery may be a fairly simple one. Unfortunately, not every Pinnacle recipient has been counseled to undergo revision surgery, making the decision much more difficult. On the surface, it may appear fairly straightforward. After all, if you have not suffered any ill effects from your DePuy Pinnacle hip device, why would you undergo a potentially risky hip revision surgery? The answer to that question is multi-faceted. Consider the following factors:

 

·         The Failure Rate of the Pinnacle

While the smaller head size of the Pinnacle (as compared to the recalled ASR) is believed to be instrumental in the lower failure rate of the Pinnacle, that failure rate is still unacceptably high. A study done in the United Kingdom concluded the Pinnacle, when used with a metal liner, had a failure rate of 8% at five years and 16% at 6.5 years. Many believe this number is considerably higher. At the time DePuy recalled the ASR, they admitted to a failure rate of 12% at five years.


·         The High Number of Adverse Event Reports

In 2010, 548 adverse event reports were sent to the FDA regarding the Pinnacle hip device. In 2011, over 1,200 additional adverse event reports were received. These adverse event reports may represent only a small portion of the total number of consumer issues related to the Pinnacle. It is generally held that only 1-10% of all adverse events are actually reported to the FDA. 

 

·         Increased Risk for Pinnacle Hip Devices with Metal Liners  

Initially the Pinnacle hip device was used in conjunction with an Ultima metal liner which resulted in friction and corrosion between the cup and the ball-shaped head. This led to the generation of excess metal ion debris flooding the body. Despite known issues with the Pinnacle, it has never been recalled, however the metal liner was discontinued in mid-2013. Patients who received a Pinnacle with the Ultima metal liner are likely at a much higher risk for failure, metallosis and metal toxicity.

 

·         Difficulties for Unrevised Patients as Evidenced by Recent Settlements

The recent settlements for the recalled Stryker Rejuvenate and ABGII hip implants as well as the DePuy ASR hip implant, have been structured in such a way that primarily, only those who have undergone hip revision surgery are eligible to reimbursement. One may speculate that those patients who still have their original Pinnacle implant may find it much harder to receive compensation for present or future injuries related to the Pinnacle under any possible future settlement agreement, should one occur. [DePuy has indicated it is strongly committed to defending its Pinnacle Hip Implant.]

 

More than 6,600 Pinnacle lawsuits have already been filed; despite a decision in favor of the defendant in late 2014, bellwether trials are currently being set. If you have experienced any symptoms of DePuy Pinnacle hip metallosis—or even if you have not—it could be beneficial to speak to a DePuy Pinnacle hip lawyer regarding potential DePuy Pinnacle hip litigation.
Print
0 Comments
Please login or register to post comments.

WARNING: Do not send any information in any email through this website if you consider the information confidential or privileged.

I understand that by submitting my contact information to Sullo & Sullo LLP for review, I consent to messages regarding this legal matter as well as marketing for other potential legal matters in the future without limitation at standard messaging and data rates unless terminated by me in writing. I further understand that my submission of any and all information in response to this website does NOT create a lawyer-client relationship between myself and Sullo & Sullo, LLP and/or its lawyers, and that any and all information submitted is NOT confidential or privileged. I further acknowledge that, unless Sullo & Sullo, LLP subsequently enters into an Attorney-Client relationship with me, any and all information I provide will NOT be treated as confidential or privileged, and any such information may be used against me and/or for the benefit of current or future clients of Sullo & Sullo, LLP. ...READ ENTIRE DISCLAIMER
Receive an Immediate Response
ANDREW SULLO IS A TOP 100 NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYER 2013 • 2014 • 2015 • 2016 • 2017 • 2018 • 2019
Obtener una Respuesta Inmediata
Andrew Sullo – 100 Mejores Abogados Nacional | 2013 • 2014 • 2015 • 2016 • 2017


4.6/5.0

STARS ON YELP
WITH OVER 400 REVIEWS*

*AS OF 2024



Andrew Sullo has been named a

TOP 100 NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYER*
2013-2024

*BY THE NATIONAL TRIAL LAWYERS

 

CALL NOW FOR A FREE LEGAL CONSULTATION
(800) 730-7607
CALL NOW FOR A FREE LEGAL CONSULTATION (713) 839-9026 CALL NOW FOR A FREE LEGAL CONSULTATION (713) 335-9485


Andrew Sullo is a recipient of the

AVVO CLIENT'S CHOICE AWARD*
2016, 2017, 2019-2024

*GIVEN BY AVVO


Justice

Andrew Sullo is a Member of the

AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF JUSTICE
2013-2024

*GRANTED BY THE AAJ

 

IF YOU OR A LOVED ONE WERE SERIOUSLY INJURED DUE TO THE NEGLIGENCE OF ANOTHER, CONTACT SULLO & SULLO IMMEDIATELY.
CALL NOW
(800) 730-7607
CALL NOW
(713) 839-9026
CALL NOW
(713) 335-9485

GET LEGAL HELP